Below is the starting point for a 50 minute talk, followed by 10 minutes of questions, given at Google on 10/5/2007 by David Weinberger. I'll know in while if the talk is a précis of Weinberger's just-published book Everything is Miscellaneous. The central point of the talk is that there is now no one right way of ordering the world; furthermore, that whereas physical things (books, stuffed animals, tools, CDs, journal articles) have to be put somewhere logical - both in space and in a physical catalogue - so that you can find either them or the record associated with them, this is not the case for digital things, which can be anywhere, and whose classification is much less relevant, provided you can search for and find them. The talk is an exploration of the changes that flow from this: to cut a long story short and to cruelly oversimplify, Weinberger's thesis is that the fundamental change that is taking place is the "externalisation of meaning", by which he means that:
- it is now simpler for citizens to organise or search digital things as they themselves decide, rather than for them to be classified for them;
- the links between digital things, and the tags and other attributes that people give them create a rich layer of meaning that can be drawn upon by others;
- the difference between data and meta-data is disappearing (except the the extent that meta-data is "what you know", and data is "what you are looking for";
- through Wikipedia and blogs and similar there is an increasingly public negotiation of knowledge, in which experts are decreasingly the arbiters of authority.
See also Nothing is miscellaneous, about the Hawley Collection of tools in Sheffield.
Does Pearson's purchase of eCollege give it the muscle to compete with Blackboard?
Long article by Scott Jaschik from the 15/5/2007 issue of Inside Higher Education about Pearson's purchase of eCollege - a US supplier of VLE services to (mainly US distance) education providers. Pearson, best known in the UK for its ownership of the Financial Times and Penguins, has a huge text-book business, and its purchase of eCollege (alongside its even bigger acquisition from Reed Elsevier of some of the publishing and assessment parts of Harcourt) brings its recent spending in this area to around $1.5 billion. The article hints at further rationalisation and consolidation between educational technology and educational content businesses, and sees eCollege, backed by Pearson as much more serious competition for Blackboard, though Blackboard's share price, today 50% higher than 3 months ago, continues to rise; and there are also interesting insights in some of the comments on Jaschik's article. For example Jim Farmer, who wrote a guest contribution in Fortnightly Mailing last year about the "post patent" environment for e-learning, highlights the extensive use made by students in the US of text-book publishers' supplementary on-line content and formative tests (to which they get time-limited access when they purchase a text-book), and the possibly greater utility of such content and tests than that provided through institutional VLEs. Chair of Becta Andrew Pinder's October 2006 call for education to "organise industrially" for it properly to exploit ICT seems to be being heeded........
Posted on 18/05/2007 in News and comment | Permalink | Comments (0)
|